Conflicts in the Implementation of Subjective Public Rights of Public Administration Subsoil Users

Journal Issue:

Author Information: 

Honored worker of the higher education of the Russian Federation, Associate Professor at the Department of Administrative and Financial Law at the Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia, Ph.D. (Law), Ph.D. (Technical Sciences).

Abstract: 

In this article author present concept that realization of subjective public rights of individuals in the sphere of public administration of subsurface use takes place in two forms: with conflict and without conflict. The most general approach to the definition of conflict is through contradiction as a more general concept. Meanwhile contradictions and conflicts, on one hand, can't be considered as synonyms, and on another – opposed to each other. Contradictions, contrasts, distinctions are all necessary, but are insufficient conditions of the conflict. Contrasts and contradictions turn into conflicts when forces being their carriers start interacting. Conflict is always an antagonism of parties with inconsistent interests. Antagonism of parties (i.e. commission by parties of certain actions directed against each other) should be understood as conflict. Application of legal norms and procedures is one of the ways for the antagonism elimination, and discrepancy or incompatibility of material and legal procedures can lead only to complications in the conflict resolution and not to its settlement.

Keywords: 

conflict, public administration, the exercise of rights; subjective public rights, rights of subsoil users, private individuals, public subjects.

REFERENCES: 

[1] Volkov AM On the question of legal conflicts in the subsoil use in the Russian Federation / Volkov AM / / Administrative law and process. - M.: 2009, № 6. with. 17.
[2] Volkov AM Legal conflicts in the subsoil. Izd. "Shield-M". 2009. -72C.
[3] Zelentsov AB The theoretical basis of the legal dispute. Dis. ... Dr. jurid. Science. 12.00.01, 12.00.14 M. 2005. - 435 p.
[4] Volkov AM Mining in Russia. Public and legal regulation. LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing. Saarbrücken, Germany. 2010. - 188s.
[5] Ibragimov VB Volkov AM Types of subsoil under the legislation of the Russian Federation / / Math. Universities. Geology and exploration. 2007. Number 3. Pp. 57 - 61.
[6] Decision of the Constitutional Court from 17.06.2004 № 12-P / / NW. 05/07/2004. Number 27. Art. 2803.
[7] Volkov AM Judicial means of resolving the legal and administrative disputes in the field of wildlife / Volkov A., EA Lyutyagin / / Administrative and municipal law. - New York: 2012. Number 7. Pp. 81-88.
[8] Resolution of the Federal District of Moscow 05.06.2006 № KA-A40/4712-06 A40-56861/05-144-294 the case number. Court of Appeal ruling of the Arbitration Court of the Republic of Bashkortostan of 23/08/2006 in case number A07-26750/05.
[9] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 05.09.2008 № A19-12089/07-F02-4235/08 A19-12089/07 the case number.
[10] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 11.12.2007 № A74-1782/07-F02-9131/07 A74-1782/07 the case number.
[11] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 29.09.2005 № A74-1485/05-F02-4660/05-S1.
[12] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 23.05.2007 № A74-4412/06-F02-2818/07 A74-4412/06 the case number.
[13] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 22.05.2008 № A19-14714/07-F02-2083/08 A19-14714/07 the case number.
[14] Volkov AM Controversial issues revised articles of the Administrative Code / / Administrative law and process. - M.: 2011, № 1. with. 41 - 43. Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 18.03.2008 № A33-8545/07-F02-828/08 A33-8545/07 the case number, and from 04.10.2007 № A33-8545/07-F02-7061/07 the case number A33-8545/07.
[15] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 27.03.2008 № F04-1642/2008 (1902-A46-31), F04-1642/2008 (2651-A46-31) in case number A46-1957/2007.
[16] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 27.02.2006 № A58-3005/04-F02-540/06-S2 A58-3005/04 the case number.
[17] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 10.10.2006 № F04-6768/2006 (27 393-A03-28) in case number A03-23856/05-10.
[18] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 02.07.2008 № A78-5780/07-S3-11/275-F02-2913/08 A78-5780/07-S3-11/275 the case number.
[19] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 04.05.2006 № F04-5209/2005 (22104-A27-3) in case number A27-4692/05-2.
[20] Kolesnik MA On the specifics of the term "mineral resource" for tax purposes / / Russian Tax Courier. 2005. Number 24. - With. 32. Mining Law: Textbook. Ed. Trubetskoy KN Volkov AM - Moscow: Publishing House of the "Shield-M", 2007. - 304s. Borisov, AN Commentary to chapter 26.04 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation "tax on mining." - Moscow: Yustitsinform. "2005. - 245s.
[21] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 06.09.2004 № F04-6291/2004 (A81-4284-34).
[22] Resolution of the Federal District of the East-Siberian from 15.07.2004 № A74-2337/03-K2-F02-2642/04-S1.
[23] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 27.11.2007 № F04-7548/2007 (40 393-A67-31) in case number A67-9507/06.
[24] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 07.06.2007 № F04-3691/2007 (35 036-A75-31) in case number A75-8977/2006.
[25] Regulations FAS West Siberian region of 14.07.2005 № F04-4408/2005 (12905-A03-10) in case number A03-12979/04-2.
[26] Resolution of the Federal Western Siberian region of 06.06.2005 № F04-3435/2005 (11 890-A81-24).
[27] Klyukin BD Problems and ways to improve the legal framework of Mining Law of the Russian Federation / / Environmental Law, 2010, N 3.
[28] Resolution of the Russian Armed Forces from 15.07.1992 № 3314-1 «On the order of the Regulation on licensing of subsoil use" / / Vedomosti SND and the Armed Forces. 08/20/1992. Number 33. Art. 1917.
[29] Dudikov MV Legal aspects of granting licenses for the use of mineral resources, which have a complex structure / / Environmental Law. 2007. Number 2. - With. 18.
[30] Klyukin BD Mountain relations in Western Europe and America. M. Gorodets-izdat. 2000. Pp. 87, 90, 131, etc. 160. Lakhno PG, F. Yu Zekker. Energy law in Russia and Germany: a comparative legal research. - Moscow: Jurist, 2011. - 1074 s.
[31] Lakhno PG, F. Yu Zekker. Energy law in Russia and Germany: a comparative legal research. - Moscow: Jurist, 2011. - S. 206, 295.
[32] Mining law: a textbook / ed. Trubetskoy KN Volkov AM - Moscow: Publishing House of the "Shield-M", 2007. - With. 54.